Why the emergence of the funny magician as a ubiquitous (to say
nothing of commercially-successful) contemporary archetype? From stars
like Penn and Teller to the guy who does tricks at your local chain restaurant
on Wednesday nights, the marriage of comedy and magic is more than good
entertainment -- it's an expression of the very principles that Miller has identified.
For it is in his calculated, controlled undermining of the Ritual's spell,
while he continues to carry us along with it, that we recognize the breathtaking
brilliance of the skilled comedic magician.
No matter how adept his legerdemain or how expert his delivery
of a one-liner, the magician-comedian's most skillful feat of all is to invite
the audience to break with the total immersion. He encourages them not
to take the tuxedo too seriously, whether it be his own or the garb of his
forebears. (In his successful bid to have it both ways, he takes care to wear
the tuxedo -- and then demystify it -- rather than simply appearing in casual
attire.) At every turn, he reminds the crowd that the show is a "highly contrived
performance" that is yet "loaded with cosmic possibility." He reveals
his pageant to be what Miller calls a mechanical puppet show, but lo and behold,
the magician-comedian remains the puppet master, pulling the strings
of his spectators by encouraging them to get the giggles.
Why is this so important and masterful an accomplishment? Miller
notes that "the demand Ritual makes on us to suspend disbelief is at times
no easy task," and the urge to get the giggles is testament to that fact. "Part
of the way Ritual achieves a feeling of sacred separation from the commonplace
is by not letting you forget that the whole thing is staged and then
asking you simultaneously to forget you know that it is staged so that you can
be transported by it." When we reflect on the tension between the sense
of immersion and the sense of unreality, some of the unique properties of
the Ritualized experience are thrown into focus. Like an absorbing fantasy
novel or a lucid dream, an effective Ritual makes the subject at once a skeptical
outsider and a fully-involved participant. Moreover, Miller claims that
"There is much comic possibility in the contrasting visions." 0
Through his individual style of patter, every magician-comedian
admits, whether explicitly or by implication, that his act is just a bunch of
hocus-pocus. And yet, as his audience giggles complicitly and aloofly on cue,
he forces them to suspend their disbelief by manipulating their very laughter.
Perhaps some of the funny magician's jokes are just throwaways, designed
more to buy time and earn audience appreciation than to cagily lampoon
his art. But, even here, any successful attempt to "involve" the audience
by engaging them with humor ultimately serves the purpose of the Ritual.
And in the hands of a masterful trickster, the amused chuckles of a comedy-
magic show's audience and the nervous titters of a Ritual's assembled can
flow back and forth as swiftly as the dice he pours from tumbler to tumbler.
Manipulation of the giggles is also intrinsic to the inspired artistry
behind another contemporary trend -- the "bizarre" magic genre. The
shocking bloody finger chops, gross-out illusions, or occult-inspired perfor
0 Ibid.